Parents of teen athletes often walk a fine line between supporting ambition and protecting well-being. On the outside, these kids seem unstoppable: balancing practices, games, schoolwork, and friendships. But beneath the surface, many teen athletes are struggling with anxiety, perfectionism, and pressure to perform. Let’s have a look at the importance of building mental fitness in teen athletes.

At Active & Connected Family Therapy, we’ve seen how easily “drive” can become “overdrive.” Teen athletes are often praised for their discipline and grit, yet the same traits that make them successful can also push them toward burnout if they’re not balancing physical training with mental health.

Prefer to listen to the podcast episode? Have a listen to the episode ‘Making Friends as an Adult’ on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube or your favorite podcast player! 

What Mental Fitness Means for Teen Athletes

When most people think about health, they think about nutrition and workouts. But mental fitness is just as essential. It’s our ability to manage emotions, stay resilient, and recover from setbacks. True health isn’t just a strong body; it’s a steady mind and a balanced life.

Coach Michael Atunrase, founder of Resilience Fitness & Sports Performance, describes mental fitness as “training your mind like you train your body.” For teen athletes, that means developing routines and mindsets that build confidence, self-awareness, and perspective.

Health is one of those things you can’t put on the back burner. You’ve got to bring it to the forefront and address it head on.

– Michael Atunrase

Here are four key practices he teaches: tools that work for teen athletes, high-achieving teens, parents, and anyone navigating a high-pressure environment.

1. Log the Work

Anxiety thrives in uncertainty. Keeping a training log helps teens see tangible proof of how much they’ve prepared. It’s important here to not just log workouts but also effort, learning, and progress. When they review their notes before a big competition, they can remind themselves: I’m prepared for this.

Additionaly, this kind of self-tracking builds self-efficacy, the belief that “I can handle what’s ahead.” It’s not about perfection, but about recognizing effort and growth.

You have to make the time. And it’s going to help you in the long run. It’s like an investment.

– Michael Atunrase 

2. Develop an Identity Beyond Sports

When a teen’s identity revolves entirely around their sport, even the smallest setback can feel devastating. That’s why diversifying identity is crucial. By joining a club, learning a creative skill, or simply spending time with friends outside the athletic world they’ll realize they are more than just an athlete.

Having more than one source of meaning allows our teens to feel success across different parts of life. Just like diversifying a financial portfolio, a “diversified identity” protects against emotional crashes when one area doesn’t go so well.

3. Practice Self-Scouting

In sports, coaches review game footage to improve future performance. But your teen can do the same for themselves: self-scouting applies the same principle. They can reflect on what helped them perform well or what made them spiral and recognize patterns before they repeat.

And even better, when they can identify their own strengths and challenges, they’ll also be able to accept feedback from others becomes easily. Self-awareness softens those sharp edges of criticism and turns it into an opportunity for growth.

4. Maintain Health Hygiene

It may sound simple, but the basics are crucial. When teens get stressed, sleep, nutrition, hygiene, and personal care often fade to the background. Taking a shower, getting enough sleep, or even dressing in a way that feels good helps ground the body and regulate emotions.

Plus, physical self-care reinforces the message that their body isn’t just a performance machine but a home that deserves attention and kindness.

Helping Teen Athletes Ride the Waves of Life

We can’t change the pressures of our achievement-driven culture, but what we can do is teach teens how to navigate it. Coach Mike uses a powerful metaphor: instead of trying to block the waves of life, we can teach our kids how to surf them.

That might mean recognizing when to push and when to rest, when to ask for help, or when to simply float for a while. Supporting the mental health of your teen athlete starts with reminding them that they’re more than their performance and that resilience isn’t about never falling, but about learning how to get back up